Reflection Eight (Final Reflection)

I feel that I have acquired various new skills whilst producing my assignments.

When gathering research for my articles I discovered it can sometimes be hard to get information from people. I had problems arranging a face to face an interview with the council and therefore had to resort to email. This was easily resolves so was therefore did not affect my assignment. I also faced problems when trying to gather information through an online survey as I struggled to get as many participants as I had hoped. However I still included this data as planned as it was evidence that supported my article.

 

Whilst producing my assignments I became more comfortable with approaching people for research. I acquired a confident and polite approach to interviews, both face to face and via email or telephone.  This is a skill that I was excited to practise and I really enjoyed meeting and talking with new people to gather a variety of opinions. I feel I managed my time well and this assignment has taught me to keep up to date with work and to follow a structured plan. I am very pleased with my final assignments.

“Garden Tax” for West Lancs

By Catherine Skelton

The West Lancashire Borough Council have decided to join many others and enforce charges for green waste disposal.

After fierce debates, what is currently a free service will now cost residents of West Lancashire £30. More and more counties, especially in the south, have began to introduce similar charges with Kingston upon Thames charging as much as £69 and Scarborough charging £38.

FullSizeRender

Wheelie bins on Scarisbrick Street Ormkirk (creative commons – Catherine Skelton)

Council budgets have been cut and  West Lancashire council representatives feel that enforcing charges is the only way to continue such services. Council representative Graham Concannon says ‘It is purely down to the financial climate across local government provision, as green waste collections are not a statutory service the options are to stop providing the service or charge.’

Backlash Can Be Expected

Despite the council’s clear lack of funds, the proposal may receive a backlash from residents who are not used to paying for such services.

An online survey reveals that 69% of people would be put off recycling green waste if they had to pay for the service. This is a risk that the council have taken as it may result in a change in attitude from residents towards recycling.

Screen Shot 2015-12-29 at 23.40.36

Online survey – surveymonkey.co.uk

However, council representatives feel that, despite these statistics, there won’t be any issues and that the charges will be accepted by most residents, who will agree to pay the charge.

“I think the general public deal with all waste in a responsible manner and they will continue in this way. It is the irresponsible few, the hard to reach groups that cause the majority of the problems.” Graham Concannon, West Lancashire council representative.

It is feared that the charge will reduce the amount of recycling residents do as the annual cost of disposal may put them off.

Mrs Anderson, resident of Scarisbrick Street, Ormskirk whilst not welcoming the charge, understands the strain that councils are under and accepts it with a sense of resignation. “The council must be struggling and this is a way of claiming back.” However for many it will be an additional bill to pay every year as Mrs Anderson adds “Along with all the other charges, I’m not keen on paying for something else but I suppose it can’t be avoided.”

The same survey also reveals that 50% of people garden less than monthly. Therefore this may mean that a large proportion of residents may not be affected by the charges on waste disposal as they will choose not to participate in the scheme.

Screen Shot 2015-12-29 at 23.38.25

Online Survey – surveymonkey.co.uk

The local area also has a high population of students and elderly which may not consider recycling as important.

“I live in a student area of West Lancs and nobody I know does any gardening or recycling and I doubt many students will pay for the service”  Thomas Poole, student at Edge Hill University.

Success For Richmond

Richmond council were one of the many councils to impose charges earlier this year. Representative, James Murphy, feels the transition was successful and caused no issues in the area.  “It hasn’t made a massive difference… residents were a bit reluctant at first but the biggest impact has been to the council’s funding”.

He then adds “It has massively improved the council’s funding and finances as we are now  able to afford to provide this service to the public”. However, if charges continue to be imposed, the cuts will eventually affect a large proportion of the population. The cost to fill green bins with compost-able material will not only affect residents but is likely to affect those in the gardening and landscaping industries as well.

The council have also considered the wages they will save for those collecting the bins. It is thought that the less people participating in the scheme, the less bin-men will be needed for collection. This may therefore lead to a reduction in jobs amongst council employees.

This could be considered a risky strategy by the council as it will inevitably mean that every penny of their future spending will be scrutinised very closely to ensure that residents’ money is spent wisely. If any unwarranted spending is identified in the future, people will question whether the charge for green waste collection is really necessary.

Many residents may feel this is a greedy attitude from the council however, with more councils imposing charges, it seems that the whole country will be paying for the disposal of green waste sooner than we think.

Have your say: www.westlancs.gov.uk/yourviews.

NI Abortion Law: “stuck in the dark ages”

By Catherine Skelton

A break through for many as Northern Ireland reveal that they have reviewed their grounds for women’s rights to pregnancy termination.

With the 1967 Abortion Act not applying to Northern Ireland, termination is only currently allowed if the mother is at serious risk physically or mentally. However, last week the department of justice recognised that adjustments need to be made to the law including cases of serious foetal malformation, rape or incest. But many people are still asking the question “why has it taken this long?”.

The recent review to the law has caused major controversy with people questioning whether these grounds are still outdated for current society. Last week, the department of justice recognised the grounds are indeed “in breach of  human rights laws” and that adjustments need to be made.

Political party Sinn Fein has recently voted to support terminations in limited cases. Political leader, Gerry Adams, spoke to ‘The Guardian’ about how he backs the motion for abortion under certain circumstances.

“Obviously, there are some women who want to continue with their pregnancy to full term and we need to support them, but there are others who feel they are not able to do that and we need to deal with both groups with the absolute maximum of support.” Adams said.

Although this recognition is a major breakthrough for the strict law of Northern Ireland, Sinn Fein are only stretching the rights to  pregnant women with fatal foetal abnormalities. Many people still believe that all women should have full control of their bodies when it comes to termination of pregnancy.

‘Barbaric, inhumane and violates human rights’

Northern Ireland’s laws could not be more different to the rest of the UK, as it is a place where politics and religion often come hand-in-hand. In England, women have up to 24 weeks for termination no matter their circumstances. Compared to the rest of the UK, Northern Ireland’s laws are extremely strict and deemed ‘old fashioned’ by members of the public. Many have taken to twitter using ‘#NIabortion’.

Bernadette Smyth, the director of the Precious Life group, has told BBC Online how she fears Northern Ireland will follow in the footsteps of the UK, with 90% of children with down syndrome being aborted.

“We are concerned that some of the judgement could lead to an opening of the floodgates here where mothers with a pro-diagnosis have access to abortion.”

The largest pro-life group in Northern Ireland the ‘Precious Life’ group are fighting to reduce the amount of women travelling to England for abortions. On their website, Bernadette goes on to say how “every baby should be cherished and protected in their parents’ arms, no matter how brief that time may be.”

Real Life Story

Northern Ireland woman, Sarah Ewart, recently went to the press with her story of how, at 20 weeks pregnant, she was forced to flee to England for an abortion. Her unborn child was diagnosed with anencephaly, a fatal condition. Despite this, it was not proven that the baby’s, nor her own life, were at risk so was not eligible for an abortion in Northern Ireland.   Sarah’s desperation brought light to the issue and caused officials to consider the case. This case raises the question as to whether the Northern Ireland’s law is stuck in the dark ages.

Sarah’s mother, Jane Christie, tells BBC News “It’s not excitement or delight, but just sheer relief”. Although, like Sarah, many women seem to be pleased with the recent breakthrough, it still only allows those with exceptional circumstances to seek a termination and this leaves many women unable to control their own body. It appears no thought has been given for these women.

After the recent breakthrough, NIHRC chief commissioner Les Allamby says “Today’s result is historic, and will be welcomed by many of the vulnerable women and girls who have been faced with these situations.”

This is a subject that seems to have sparked fierce debate both in the court room and on social media and despite the recent acknowledgement to women’s rights, it may not be what many were hoping for.